My grade 6 students have been busy putting together an epic fantasy story book suitable for a middle school readership. This team had something of an artistic disagreement when putting the final book together which resulted in this alternative version:

This is a creative, collaborative fantasy adventure written in the style of a middle-grade or young adult novel. The themes are positive—focusing on friendship, courage, loyalty, sacrifice, and the triumph of good over evil. The story is imaginative and follows a clear hero’s journey.

Content Notes:

1. Violence/Fantasy Action:
   There are battle scenes, magical fights, and encounters with creatures (Yetis, dragons, a Time Guardian, etc.). The violence is not graphic or gory; it is typical of fantasy adventures (e.g., “slicing his head off,” “defeated the dragon,” “turning to dust”). No detailed injuries or suffering are described.

2. Emotional Themes:

   • A father disappears early in the story.

   • A main character (Arthur) dies sacrificially at the end. This is handled with dignity and grief, followed by a funeral and memorial.

   • Characters express sadness, anger, and loss, but these are resolved positively.

3. Moral & Ethical Messages:
   The story promotes:

   • Helping others and protecting the weak.

   • The power of friendship and teamwork.

   • Standing up against evil.

   • Consequences for actions (the Dark Wizard is defeated).

   • There is a brief debate about whether to offer the villain a chance (Chapter 8), which reinforces ethical thinking.

4. Language & Tone:
   The writing is child-friendly and at times whimsical (e.g., using honey cake as a weapon). No profanity, offensive language, or inappropriate content was found.

5. Cultural or Social Sensitivity:
   No insensitive stereotypes or problematic depictions were noted. Characters are mythical beings (elves, dwarves, trolls, etc.) or original creations.

Recommendation:

This story is appropriate for a school library, likely best suited for grades 4–8 (ages 9–14), depending on reading level and maturity. The themes are constructive, the conflict is fantasy-based, and the resolution is thoughtful.

Minor Considerations:

• The collaborative authorship means writing styles and pacing vary, but this does not affect appropriateness.

• The death of a main character may be emotionally impactful for very young readers, but it is presented as heroic and meaningful, not traumatic.

2